While there are many fine young singers on Canadian Idol, I find the judges comments lacklustre and unenlightening.
The judges have a tendency to back each other up rather than giving individualist, thoughtful and well considered opinion. I hate to say this but the "experts" on Canadian Idol are worse than those on American Idol.
The more passionate and specific a judge can be on a performance. The more the performer and audience can benefit from the analysis.
I find the best music critics and reviewers are columists in newspapers. They tell they audience exactly what they like or dislike in a performance and then rate the entertainer on a star system. No such quality or quantity assessment exists on Canadian/American Idol.
For the above reasons, I'll only watch the occasional show.
Canadian Idol
Posted by qualteam
at 11:18 PM EDT
Updated: Thursday, 8 July 2004 11:21 PM EDT